Alright so we'll start with the best heroines then, in no particular order.
First up is:
Satonaka Chie from Persona 4. She is beautiful and nice. She also wears delicious spats. She is the best heroine out of any Persona game.
Misaka Mikoto from To Aru Majutsu no Index. Best tsundere ever award. Also perfect age range for me... I'm not lolicon by the way.
|It was hard to find non-lewd pictures.|
...Asuka from Evangelion. She is so attractive it's crazy. Although she is a little tsun her dere is great!
Tsukimiya Ayu from Kanon. The original moe from the original nakige (no arguing allowed). Uguu...
Suzumiya Akane from Kimi ga Nozomu Eien. Really the only reason to read the VN. She is great, younger, and yea. The fandisc is nice too because you can court her before the accident~
Hinamori Amu from Shugo Chara. Although I don't approve of her boy harem and her letting older boys at her house... she is still moe.
Now for the 10 worst characters. Remember, this is indisputable.
Kusoneko from Ore no Imouto. She is a garbage friend to Kirino, is a hipster, has shit taste in anime and manga, writes dumb fanfics, and probably smells bad. She is an ugly fujoshi. And she is trying to NTR Kirino.
Itsuwa from To Aru Majutsu no Index. She is a trash heroine added halfway through the series. Nobody except a small vocal minority likes her (fact, don't argue) and she gets way too much attention to her in the novels. I hope she disappears.
Meiya from Muv-Luv. She is a dumb character. She met the protagonist, for one day, when they were both like 4 or 5, and he apparently said he would marry her. So like 12 or 13 years later she comes to live with him against his consent to fulfill this promise? Who the hell does she think she is? She played with the guy once when they were pretty much babies and somehow she deserves to come into the scene and expect to hook up with him? I don't think so. Muv-Luv would be better if she was the only one that died.
Haruhi from...Haruhi. I don't think I really need to say that much right? She is a bitch.
Taiga from Toradora. She is the worst kind of character. Abusive, dumb, fake tsundere, etc. She does not deserve to have her feelings rewarded. Minorin did.
Ohana from Hanasaku Iroha. Another typical slut voiced by Itou Kanae. Although she has a very bad mother so it isn't all Ohana's fault she turned out the way she did.
Toosaka Rin from Fate/Stay Night. She is lewd, bisexual, and is a bitch to her poor imouto.
Konata from Lucky Star. Another ugly fujoshi character meant to appeal to the stinky otaku crowd. "Konata likes anime and galge! Just like me! K-Konata..."
Tomoyo from Clannad. Biggest Mary Sue character in a VN. She is violent and lewd. Not moe at all. Has an awful route in the VN and an awful fandisc.
Yui from K-ON. I applaud KyoAni for having it in them to make an anime with a cast of mentally handicapped characters, but they went too far with Yui. Sometimes I wonder how she even remembers to breath considering how retarded she is. I'm not sure what's worse, the fact that a character like her exists, or the fact that there are people that actually like her.
That's all for now.